Animal characters can boost young children’s psychological development

A new study by our School of Psychology explored the extent to which different characters influence children’s theory of mind skills
Getty images - primary school children
Children’s books are full of animal characters whose antics capture the hearts and inspire the imaginations of their young readers.
However, a new study has shown that iconic characters such as Peter Rabbit – or Toad and Ratty from The Wind in the Willows – can also play an important role in children’s psychological development.
The research explored the extent to which different non-human characters influence children’s theory of mind skills, which include the ability to read and predict social changes in the environment through tone of voice, choice of words, or facial expression.
For the study, more than 100 children aged between five and ten were tested on their theory of mind skills when presented with stories featuring animal characters as opposed to those featuring human ones.
The study found that when faced with human characters, there was a clear age-related progression, with older children consistently outperforming their younger counterparts. In fact, Year 3 children performed better than the researchers had predicted in the tests featuring human characters.
However, in tests that involved animal characters, Year 1 participants were able to match the scores achieved by pupils from Year 3, two years older than them.
Writing in the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, the researchers say the findings highlight the importance of both human and non-human characters for children’s earliest development.
The research was led by Dr Gray Atherton and Dr Liam Cross , from the University of Plymouth’s School of Psychology .

Animals play a huge part of children’s stories, whether that is in books and comics or through TV and film.

We wanted to test if that is down to more than simply liking the characters, and whether there are actual benefits of children learning through watching or reading about animals and if this changes over time. Our findings showed that both human and non-human characters are important in helping children interpret the world around them, and that they play differing roles at different stages in their development. Adapting activities and lessons in nurseries and the early school years to take that into account could be hugely effective in helping to support their development.

Gray AthertonDr Gray Atherton
Lecturer in Psychology

The research builds on previous studies by Dr Atherton and Dr Cross exploring factors which can influence the educational and social development of people with autism and learning difficulties.
These have included initiatives showing that playing board and online games can boost the confidence among people with autism, and others highlighting that people with dyslexia and dyscalculia show reduced bias against others based on characteristics such as their disability, race or gender.
Based on the new research, the academics now intend to explore in more detail if their findings could be used specifically to benefit children with such conditions.

We believe this new study could have particular importance for people with autism or other conditions which can impact their learning. Working with teenagers in the past, we have noticed how tasks that involve animal characters can result in autistic people performing just as well as non-autistic children. It would be interesting to replicate our current study with autistic children, to understand if we can find more effective ways to support them at a critical point in their development.

Liam CrossDr Liam Cross
Lecturer in Psychology

  • The full study – Atherton, Robinson, Guy-Smith and Cross: The wind in the willows effect: Does age affect human versus animal faux pas recognition? – is published in the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, DOI: 10.1016/j.jecp.2024.106116.

Read more about our research linked to this project

Tabletop gaming with dice

Dungeons and Dragons can help autistic people gain confidence and find their inner hero

Child playing bean boardgame

Why are board games so popular among many people with autism? New research explains

Colourful silhouettes of people with different internal illustrations, numbers and characters representing neurodiversity

People with dyslexia and dyscalculia show less bias, study shows

 

School of Psychology

As one of the largest and best resourced psychology departments in the UK, we share our expertise and enthusiasm with over 800 students and offer undergraduate and postgraduate courses, and a Doctorate in Clinical Psychology, with accreditation by the British Psychological Society.
Certificate of Professional Development Foundations in Psychology