Saturated soils could impact survival of young trees planted to address climate change

New research looked into the potential effects of increased rainfall in regions being earmarked for expansion of the UK’s temperate rainforests
Tree planting at Forder Farm, Dartmoor, part of efforts to expand woodland as part of the Dartmoor Headwaters Pilot Project (Credit - Lloyd Russell, University of Plymouth)
The saturated soil conditions predicted to result from increased rainfall in the UK’s upland regions could have a knock-on effect on the ambition to create more woodland in the fight against climate change, a new study has found.
Researchers from the University of Plymouth have spent a number of years exploring how temperate rainforests could be an effective nature-based solution to some of the planet’s greatest challenges.
They have also shown that the UK’s uplands could in future see significantly more annual rainfall than is currently being predicted in national climate models.
In new research, they found that higher soil water levels within areas such as Dartmoor, the Lake District and the Scottish Highlands could have a significant impact on the survival rates of both acorns and juvenile oak saplings.
Published in the journal Forest Ecology and Management, it is the first study to highlight the importance of factoring in soil conditions when looking at where and how to create the temperate rainforests of the future.

In recent years, there have been increasing calls to plant more trees as part of the global effort to combat climate change. Restoration and expansion of temperate rainforests, which are a globally rare ecosystem, is seen as one of the potential solutions. But with our previous work also predicting an increase in future rainfall we wanted to know if the woodlands we create will support naturally colonising trees in future. Our results show that higher water levels within soils directly contribute to reduced survival of both acorns and young oak trees. We believe it provides landowners, land managers and policy makers with important information as to which species might work in particular locations to support more resilient future rainforests.

Thomas MurphyDr Thomas Murphy
Lecturer in Environmental Sciences

For the study, researchers planted acorns from English oaks (Quercus robur) in containers with four soil states, from completely flooded to low saturation where the water level was 220mm below the acorn.
The acorns did not survive in the flooded soils, but survival rates improved gradually – 43% at high saturation, 77% at medium saturation, and 83% at low saturation – as the water level dropped.
The surviving seedlings also exhibited reduced root:shoot ratio, leaf photosynthesis, and a lower likelihood of late season shoot growth in soils of higher saturation.
In a concurrent field experiment, juvenile English oak and Sessile oak (Quercus petraea) saplings were planted in a region of Dartmoor that is seasonally waterlogged and frequented by grazing livestock.
In these tests, the English oaks exhibited greater shoot growth and leaf photosynthesis than its close relation in areas where the soil was more saturated.
The researchers, including environmental scientists and ecologists, say the results highlight the need for better understanding of soil influence on tree development.

There has been extensive talk about how larger trees respond to the effects of climate change. But these results show we need to factor in the response of young trees as well, especially if they are being envisioned as an integral part of the solution. By examining their response to conditions now, while also thinking about what these locations are going to be like in 50 years’ time, we can better understand the right trees for the right locations, and hopefully make these woodlands more resilient in the long-term.

Dr Thomas Murphy
  • The full study – Murphy et al: Soil saturation limits early oak establishment in upland pastures for restoration of Atlantic oak woodlands – is published in Forest Ecology and Management, DOI: 10.1016/j.foreco.2024.121895.
Atlantic oak woodland at Piles Copse on Dartmoor, UK, was studied to better understand oak regeneration into upland pastures (Credit - Lloyd Russell, University of Plymouth)

Study shows how temperate rainforests can aid the fight against climate change

Belver tor, Dartmoor

Future rainfall could far outweigh current climate predictions, study suggests

Trees on ancient Dartmoor woodland

New woodlands can help reduce flooding risk within 15 years

Gina test temperate rainforest map